Decided to try them first on my black Tele, so I set too with that scroll saw and files, and produced this, using Motown Chartbusters 3, Side 2

A close up....

Going to keep a look out for more iconic labels, but I have to stress I only buy 'em if they are badly scratched. The idea of hacking into a playable album doesn't appeal.
The beauty of the Telecaster is that you can change its look with 5 minutes with a screwdriver. This black Tele wears any one of about 5 or 6 different pickguards.
Heck, I could change them between sets


Shame though because the size of an LP is not quite big enough for some guitars like Strats and Squier '51s, though I think you could make one for a Jaguar/Jazzmaster, and certainly for a Mustang of a Bronco.
Don't have to stick with soul labels either, would look good with other iconic labels IMO