
I'll up date as I get the time to do a bit...
Moderated By: mods
gonna have to stop you there!!!! i hope you don't sleepwalk into getting a trapeze tailpiece (which would be great) and a TOM, or any monstrosity like the one in the video that doesn't have individual string intonation. notice how he didn't play past the 3rd fret? yeah...dezb1 wrote:The bridge is shite so I have a cunning plan for a replacement.
Going to do the one one the video, had a chat with a bloke on ttippi (or whatever it's called Tele forum) says he has a Nash and he has to get above the 12th fret before he gets any problems also the bloke from Low has one and makes some nice noises... I mean 12 string acoustics don't have individual adjustments and they do Awreet. And if all else fails I'll have a go with the supplied bridge but it just looks like a major faff, think electric players just have to much OCD when it comes to perfect intonation.George wrote:gonna have to stop you there!!!! i hope you don't sleepwalk into getting a trapeze tailpiece (which would be great) and a TOM, or any monstrosity like the one in the video that doesn't have individual string intonation. notice how he didn't play past the 3rd fret? yeah...dezb1 wrote:The bridge is shite so I have a cunning plan for a replacement.
can't wait to see the results though. love 12 strings.
Acoustics and electrics play by different rules, because the pickups on electrics are listening at only one point on the strings. That means electrics sound like crap if the harmonics aren't all precisely intonated. On an acoustic the whole string is being amplified by the soundhole, so you get all the harmonics (not just a subset) and the harmonics of the different strings mesh together to give that rich shimmery sound, so you don't need a precision-intonating bridge. But if you stuck a pickup at one point along the strings, it would sound dead and a bit sour by comparison.dezb1 wrote:I mean 12 string acoustics don't have individual adjustments and they do Awreet.
i disagree and it sounds like you're flirting a little with mojo arrows here. acoustic and electric 12 strings sound like hot garbage past the 7th fret, especially on the A and D strings with a wound and an unwound string together if they don't have individual intonation or compensation in some way.MatthewK wrote:Acoustics and electrics play by different rules, because the pickups on electrics are listening at only one point on the strings. That means electrics sound like crap if the harmonics aren't all precisely intonated. On an acoustic the whole string is being amplified by the soundhole, so you get all the harmonics (not just a subset) and the harmonics of the different strings mesh together to give that rich shimmery sound, so you don't need a precision-intonating bridge. But if you stuck a pickup at one point along the strings, it would sound dead and a bit sour by comparison.dezb1 wrote:I mean 12 string acoustics don't have individual adjustments and they do Awreet.
Yr probably right, I have no experience with 12 strings. But the arguments generally apply to 6 strings, I mean can you imagine a solidbody electric sounding good with a single angled bone saddle? And yet a D28 sounds sweet and well intonated.George wrote:i disagree and it sounds like you're flirting a little with mojo arrows here. acoustic and electric 12 strings sound like hot garbage past the 7th fret, especially on the A and D strings with a wound and an unwound string together if they don't have individual intonation or compensation in some way.
There is a school of thought that says the jangle comes from the fact that you can't get the intonation perfect, like you say above and that a 12 string wouldn't sound right with perfect intonation.George wrote:i disagree and it sounds like you're flirting a little with mojo arrows here. acoustic and electric 12 strings sound like hot garbage past the 7th fret, especially on the A and D strings with a wound and an unwound string together if they don't have individual intonation or compensation in some way.MatthewK wrote:Acoustics and electrics play by different rules, because the pickups on electrics are listening at only one point on the strings. That means electrics sound like crap if the harmonics aren't all precisely intonated. On an acoustic the whole string is being amplified by the soundhole, so you get all the harmonics (not just a subset) and the harmonics of the different strings mesh together to give that rich shimmery sound, so you don't need a precision-intonating bridge. But if you stuck a pickup at one point along the strings, it would sound dead and a bit sour by comparison.dezb1 wrote:I mean 12 string acoustics don't have individual adjustments and they do Awreet.
there's really a reason why you don't say players venturing past the 3rd/5th fret on many 12 strings (check youtube, check classic tracks etc). they may use the G, B and high E strings sparingly but otherwise they steer clear. i know that you get the swirly chorus effect of a slight intonation mismatch, but this quickly turns to dissonance the further up you go and it makes the vast majority of the neck unusable. just like that tele video in this thread with that abomination bridge - call him up and ask him to jangle, do single line leads or chords past the 7th fret. unless he's got some kind of complex compensated nut it'd be hilarious.
it depends what you want, but imo most 12 string setups are not practical for the upper frets at all unless you have compensated or individually adjustable saddles.