J or P? or a short-scale?

Talk about all other types of guitars. Jazzmasters and basses go here!

Moderated By: mods

EddieN
.
.
Posts: 17
Joined: Thu Feb 01, 2007 5:53 pm

Post by EddieN »

James wrote:The main difference from a playability point of view is the nut width. The J is much narrower than the P to the point where if you're used to one, changing feels quite awkward at first. I personally prefer the J width, and I think it was designed to make it easier to switch between guitar and bass. Go to a music shop and try both a a J and a P pretending that you're interesting in buying one (play the Fender type). Then when you have an idea how they each play, buy a copy online.

The main difference with a regard to the sound comes from the pickups. The J pickups have a wider range, but the P gets a 'growl' the J can't quite do. Although I love the sound of the P style pickup, a J is probably better for the style you want to play.

If you need any convincing, James Jamerson and Bootsy (in his early days) used Jazz basses.
Excellent post but...uh...
Image
Altho' I've also read somewhere he briefly had a Fender V, there's no mentions ever of him playing Jazz. Just Precisions & double bass. Just sayin' for the record.
User avatar
James
Nutmeg
Posts: 10645
Joined: Thu Jul 13, 2006 6:15 pm
Location: Boxingham Palace

Post by James »

EddieN wrote:
James wrote:The main difference from a playability point of view is the nut width. The J is much narrower than the P to the point where if you're used to one, changing feels quite awkward at first. I personally prefer the J width, and I think it was designed to make it easier to switch between guitar and bass. Go to a music shop and try both a a J and a P pretending that you're interesting in buying one (play the Fender type). Then when you have an idea how they each play, buy a copy online.

The main difference with a regard to the sound comes from the pickups. The J pickups have a wider range, but the P gets a 'growl' the J can't quite do. Although I love the sound of the P style pickup, a J is probably better for the style you want to play.

If you need any convincing, James Jamerson and Bootsy (in his early days) used Jazz basses.
Excellent post but...uh...
Image
Altho' I've also read somewhere he briefly had a Fender V, there's no mentions ever of him playing Jazz. Just Precisions & double bass. Just sayin' for the record.
Right you are. My mistake.

I'd still say that the best value for money will be an OLP, but try the two standard Fenders too.
Shabba.
More Cowbell
.
.
Posts: 6206
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 3:31 am
Location: Jefferson, GA

Post by More Cowbell »

I got this MIM J bass @ guitar center for $249

Image
User avatar
MaMo
.
.
Posts: 972
Joined: Mon Sep 29, 2008 9:30 pm
Location: San Francisco,CA
Contact:

Post by MaMo »

damn, block inlays and everything? Nicely done.
scandoslav wrote:i heard these are wank when it comes to metal
RUN AMOK!.
User avatar
Sublimedo
.
.
Posts: 2656
Joined: Sun Aug 13, 2006 9:24 am
Location: SO CAL
Contact:

Post by Sublimedo »

More Cowbell wrote:I got this MIM J bass @ guitar center for $249

Image
I SAY, GODDAMMN. Always have loved that thing.
User avatar
Bacchus
Whatever's handiest
Posts: 23590
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 4:10 am
Location: wandering

Post by Bacchus »

Nicest bass, ever.
Image
User avatar
Billy3000
.
.
Posts: 3033
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 3:16 am
Location: Atlanta

Post by Billy3000 »

MaMo wrote:damn, block inlays and everything? Nicely done.
damn! Is that an all parts neck?
User avatar
Chorlton
.
.
Posts: 628
Joined: Sat Apr 05, 2008 8:58 pm

Post by Chorlton »

i picked up a cheap epiphone thunderbird. sounds good and and is super comfy to play. looks killer. neck dive can be sorted out be moving the strap lock.
User avatar
MaMo
.
.
Posts: 972
Joined: Mon Sep 29, 2008 9:30 pm
Location: San Francisco,CA
Contact:

Post by MaMo »

Chorlton wrote:i picked up a cheap epiphone thunderbird. sounds good and and is super comfy to play. looks killer. neck dive can be sorted out be moving the strap lock.
That's what my bass player did with his, he said the neck dive was crazy beforehand. The pickups on those sound great, btw.
scandoslav wrote:i heard these are wank when it comes to metal
RUN AMOK!.
More Cowbell
.
.
Posts: 6206
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 3:31 am
Location: Jefferson, GA

Post by More Cowbell »

Billy3000 wrote:
MaMo wrote:damn, block inlays and everything? Nicely done.
damn! Is that an all parts neck?
No...its the Stock neck, I put the inlays in it. Bass inlays are so easy, its like changing spark plugs on a truck under the hood...you have so much room to use the router. Its the best inlay job I've ever done, its perfect. Ask Arsecake, he played it for our pixies submat.
User avatar
Billy3000
.
.
Posts: 3033
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 3:16 am
Location: Atlanta

Post by Billy3000 »

More Cowbell wrote:
Billy3000 wrote:
MaMo wrote:damn, block inlays and everything? Nicely done.
damn! Is that an all parts neck?
No...its the Stock neck, I put the inlays in it. Bass inlays are so easy, its like changing spark plugs on a truck under the hood...you have so much room to use the router. Its the best inlay job I've ever done, its perfect. Ask Arsecake, he played it for our pixies submat.
Sweet... I might have to let you do that to the neck on my jazz bass whenever I'm down that way!
More Cowbell
.
.
Posts: 6206
Joined: Thu Apr 20, 2006 3:31 am
Location: Jefferson, GA

Post by More Cowbell »

Sounds like a plan.