OK, so what I wound up ordering was a pair of Kluson SD9105MNP. According to what I could find out, they have 6mm posts (the same as stock Ping tuners) and should fit. We'll see. I got them via ebay from a dealer called Ant Hill Music for $39.95:
http://cgi.ebay.com/KLUSON-SD9105MNP-NI ... 563d44f2ed
I was hesitant to try the Gotohs, mainly because I recently purchased a pair of (non-returnable
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2d2b7/2d2b77e7f7d72d1681f036d9c8da146d961e4e87" alt="Mad :mad:"
) white button SD91 Gotohs from ebay that were listed as "Strat Tele Mustang"; the only thing is, the shafts are .250" (1/4") in diameter, so they don't work with my existing bushings, and I'd have to drill out my headstock to use their (included) bushings. I didn't feel like drilling. Since I couldn't get any of the dealers to get back to me with confirmation of the shaft diameters on the ones Rob recommended, I went with something that I felt would fit. We'll know for sure if they will or not in a week or so when they arrive. I'll report back when they do.
Also, for future reference for anyone looking for white button tuners, here's a few links you may find useful:
First, a couple of additional sources for the Gotohs that Rob recommended:
Allparts has them for $50.
http://www.allparts.com/Gotoh-6-in-line ... 80-001.htm
Guitar Parts Resource has them for $39.79 (third row down - part #TK-0980-001).
http://www.guitarpartsresource.com/tune ... egotoh.htm
And Guitar Parts Site has them for $32.99
http://www.guitarpartssite.com/Gotoh-TK ... 001-ap.htm
Hope that's helpful for someone somewhere down the line. Cheers.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/30128/301287950893e09d8fcaa99baca8cdc6f6412b34" alt="Smile :)"