Finishing worn spots on neck?

[Will]

So I'm contemplating committing the cardinal sin of vintage guitar ownership. My '57 Dano's finish is worn through by the first few frets. The neck is softer poplar, and the wood has started to wear away rather quickly. There's a clear ridge where the poplar meets the rosewood and the first fret pokes out a bit as well. I want to stop the wood from wearing away anymore without changing the look of the natural wear.

After reading a bit, I'm considering Tung Oil. Basically rubbing in many thin, light coats to create a matte seal and build up a little thickness. I'd hope that by hand-rubbing I could blend the new and old finish well.

My question is: is this a good way to fix the problem? Any better methods? What should I be aware of when doing this? I'm not at all concerned about resale and, in any case, I'd try to make the new finish invisible.

[SKC Willie]

some people are really good with those rub on finishes . . . but I didn't have very good luck the first time.


I think it is like any finishing, it takes a little practice. So, if it is important for you to get a good looking clear, you may want to just do whatever you're most comfortable with.

[cur]

Is it a painted neck? Tung oil or Danish finish oil might Be a good start. Put it on thick and let it soak in. They penetrate and will harden. A light dusting of lacquer over that might be helpful as well.

Do you have a pic?