J/P bass dilema
Posted: Wed Jan 16, 2013 8:30 am
So a couple years ago i scored a P bass from a child hood friend. when we were 13 and 14 we decided to start a band. I bought a guitar, cuz it was cheaper, and his parents bought him a 1996 MIM CAR P bass. He never really learned to play and it basically sat in his room thru high school then eventually went up in his parents attic. years later, i asked him if he had it and he said he would have to look around his parents attic. Bottom line is he found it, and sold it to me for $150 bucks. It was is decent condition, just kinda dinged up from sitting around a teenagers room not being played for 4 or 5 years. And then it sat in a cold uninsulated Washington state attic for ten years.
Once i got it i cleaned it up, got some GFS P bass pups for it, swapped the pickguard to black (was white) and put some new knobs on it. I loved it. It sounded great. The nostalgia is a big part of it. I got my Harmony guitar (my very first guitar, i had never even touched one before that) and he got his the same week. I'm primarily a bass player now and i usually play my ibanez 5 string. I recently joined another metal band and i don't need the low B so i was stoked i'd be able to use my P bass.... The neck on that fucker is like a baseball bat. The whole guitar seems incredibly solid for a MIM P bass. I did some reading and mine has a solid black Fender logo. and i from what i hear is its basically a MIA parts bass assembled in mexico. can anyone verify that? I've played some mexican fender basses and they all seem like toys in comparison.
anyways here's the second half of the story. I scored a "crafted in indonesia" squier jazz bass from a bro deal with a buddy involving a trade for an old ibanez bass i had for his J bass + cash. I intended on making the jazz bass a project because he totally fucked the electronics etc with his back alley guitar work and soldering. I loved the way the neck felt. No so much that specific neck, but just the jazz bass neck. i've owned a few jazz bases and the necks were always great. So i thought i'd get cute and swap necks. The P bass fit perfect into the jazz body, but the J neck was too wide for the P bass body. So with a shitload of sandpaper, and about 3 hours to kill today, i sanded it down to fit. everything is sound. I didnt have to adjust the saddles or anything it was perfectly intonated. all i did was lower the saddles a bit.
So now to the weird part... It may not be a "vintage badass instrument" or anything, but i feel like im commiting a crime with a indonesian neck on a 1996 P bass. It doesnt seem to sound as good as before... im not sure if its just me knowing its a cheap neck on it or what. It's not really THAT noticeable but im convinced it isn't as good. I sanded down the J bass neck (not complete bare wood) because it felt sticky and i originally thought i was gonna make it part of the J bass project and thought a blank neck would look good. Now i think the P bass with a blank headstock just looks weak. I almost just want to forget it, and put it back together the way they were. Overall, the P bass plays better with the J neck, but i don't enjoy it as much knowing that it is a cheap neck... I'm almost thinking i liked that bass better knowing it was the same exact bass i played when i was smoking pot out of my buddies window when i was 15 staying over at his house. Even if functionally its not as good as i wish it was.
Once i got it i cleaned it up, got some GFS P bass pups for it, swapped the pickguard to black (was white) and put some new knobs on it. I loved it. It sounded great. The nostalgia is a big part of it. I got my Harmony guitar (my very first guitar, i had never even touched one before that) and he got his the same week. I'm primarily a bass player now and i usually play my ibanez 5 string. I recently joined another metal band and i don't need the low B so i was stoked i'd be able to use my P bass.... The neck on that fucker is like a baseball bat. The whole guitar seems incredibly solid for a MIM P bass. I did some reading and mine has a solid black Fender logo. and i from what i hear is its basically a MIA parts bass assembled in mexico. can anyone verify that? I've played some mexican fender basses and they all seem like toys in comparison.
anyways here's the second half of the story. I scored a "crafted in indonesia" squier jazz bass from a bro deal with a buddy involving a trade for an old ibanez bass i had for his J bass + cash. I intended on making the jazz bass a project because he totally fucked the electronics etc with his back alley guitar work and soldering. I loved the way the neck felt. No so much that specific neck, but just the jazz bass neck. i've owned a few jazz bases and the necks were always great. So i thought i'd get cute and swap necks. The P bass fit perfect into the jazz body, but the J neck was too wide for the P bass body. So with a shitload of sandpaper, and about 3 hours to kill today, i sanded it down to fit. everything is sound. I didnt have to adjust the saddles or anything it was perfectly intonated. all i did was lower the saddles a bit.
So now to the weird part... It may not be a "vintage badass instrument" or anything, but i feel like im commiting a crime with a indonesian neck on a 1996 P bass. It doesnt seem to sound as good as before... im not sure if its just me knowing its a cheap neck on it or what. It's not really THAT noticeable but im convinced it isn't as good. I sanded down the J bass neck (not complete bare wood) because it felt sticky and i originally thought i was gonna make it part of the J bass project and thought a blank neck would look good. Now i think the P bass with a blank headstock just looks weak. I almost just want to forget it, and put it back together the way they were. Overall, the P bass plays better with the J neck, but i don't enjoy it as much knowing that it is a cheap neck... I'm almost thinking i liked that bass better knowing it was the same exact bass i played when i was smoking pot out of my buddies window when i was 15 staying over at his house. Even if functionally its not as good as i wish it was.